This web site accommodates affiliate hyperlinks. As an Amazon Affiliate, I earn a fee from qualifying purchases at no additional value to you. Full Disclosure Right here.
In terms of water filters there are many corporations to select from. Over the previous couple of years, it appears nearly everybody has been making an attempt to capitalize on the necessity for a small and dependable water filter that’s as finances pleasant as potential.
A few of you’ll have learn my evaluations on the Survivor Filter already and be conversant in it. The Lifestraw has been round longer and loads of fellow preppers have a number of of those readily available. At our place we preserve one within the truck simply in case we get caught out someplace.
At underneath the worth it was an excellent deal on the time and 264 gallons of filtration (Lifestraw just lately up to date this to 1,000 gallons) is greater than sufficient to do if two individuals are making an attempt to make it residence.
After making an attempt out the Survivor Filter (full assessment right here!) it bought me pondering that the Lifestraw (Full assessment right here!) was good when it got here out however there are higher choices to your cash on the market. On this put up I’m going to check the Lifestraw to the Survivor filter so you may make a extra knowledgeable choice when shopping for this fashion of filter.
Lifestraw Specs
Filters: Micro organism and Protozoa. This consists of E-Coli and Giardia. Lifestraw has been examined and located to filter out 99.9999% of micro organism and 99.9% of Protozoa.
Filtration Degree: 0.2 microns reduces the turbidity of water. That is notably vital when getting water out of lakes, swamps, or after rain or giant snow melts.
Lifespan Of Filter:Â Initially reported to be 1000 Liters or 264 gallons. Lifestraw now says that assessments point out their filters are good for 4,000 liters or round 1,000 gallons. Their web site signifies that the bigger declare is true even if in case you have purchased one in every of their earlier straws.
Substitute Filters Accessible: Lifestraws don’t have replacements. You must purchase one other full Lifestraw
Professionals:
- Cheap and straightforward to search out at quite a few on-line retailers and out of doors suppliers.
- Made within the USA reasonably than in a rustic with much less high quality checks and guidelines
Cons:
- Solely sensible for brief to medium time period survival conditions as a result of 1,000-4,000 liter lifespan.
- No prefilter so sediment and different particles could be extra of an issue and even clog the primary filter up quicker than anticipated so your filter can fail sooner.
Filters: Micro organism, Protozoa, and Viruses
Price:Â (verify right here for the newest)
Filtration Degree: 0.05 microns
Lifespan of Filter: This filter is rated to be good for over 26,000 gallons which suggests it has the filtration capability of 7-26 Lifestraws (relying on which determine you go together with for lifespan.
Saying 1,000 liters after which upping it to 4,000 appears iffy to me) whereas solely costing $10-$15 greater than the Lifestraw. This implies your water filtration prices go all the way down to $0.001153 per liter!
Substitute Filters: Each filter part on the Survivor Filter is replaceableand can be cleaned for an improved lifespan. The prefilter helps preserve the extent of stream excessive and helps the primary filter final far longer.
Professionals: Accommodates a sediment prefilter made from cotton that may be cleaned and reused many occasions however the filter comes with a package deal of those so you might have some extras readily available from the beginning.
Cons: I do know it would sound trivial to some however Survivor Filter is international made. I really feel that I’ve to let readers know this earlier than they purchase so they aren’t upset later. I believe Survivor Filter is a top quality filter no matter the place it’s manufactured.
Hydration Pack & Group Concerns
Utilizing both filter inline with a hydration again isn’t potential with the Lifestraw. Don’t get me fallacious, 1000 liters of pure and clear consuming water is sufficient to get a household by way of loads of conditions I might consider however you will must go the straw round.
At a price of 10 liters of water a day a Lifestraw might get you thru a 100 days. 10 liters is simply over 2.5 gallons which would supply 3.3 Liters of water per individual for a household of 4.
That could be a very beneficiant water allowance particularly if water is simply getting used for consuming and lightweight cooking. I believe a household of 4 might simply get by way of 4 months with a bit consideration however it might not be simple.
 I like that the squeeze canteens you should buy individually or as a part of the Survivor Filter package deal could be used when mandatory and you’ll screw it onto an ordinary soda bottle if wanted.
For those who like Lifestraw, there’s a new product from them known as the Lifestraw Flex.
This may be purchased and can be utilized inline with a hydration pack! For a gaggle scenario this might be much better than an everyday Lifestraw and price lower than shopping for loads of Lifestraws.
Different Concerns When Selecting A Water Filter
Please make it possible for if you find yourself contemplating any water filter to consider how simple it might be for you personally to make use of. Sucking up water isn’t going to be simple for some however utilizing a squeeze bag is perhaps far more manageable and lifelike.
Lifestraw Bargains
Typically I’ve to say which you could get an distinctive deal on Lifestraws in bulk. They aren’t a foul buy in any respect in the event you discover them on sale or simply need a fast and straightforward filter that’s well-known. They could be a good technique to get others launched to the concept of prepping and look much less intimidating than some filters.
Different Filters In Each Households
Survivor Filter Professional
The makers of Survivor Filter additionally make a helpful pump filter that I actually like. It comes with a cup to filter into and it is vitally light-weight. Like all Survivor Filter merchandise, you may get alternative filters for it. The pump is less complicated in your hand then loads of filters I’ve had just like the MSR Sweetwater.
Lifestraw Household Of Merchandise
Lifestraw makes some superb merchandise beyond the Lifestraw. The Lifestraw Mission or Household Filter are each good values. In actual fact if you’re going for a straightforward to make use of group filter, the Lifestraw Household filters loads of water utilizing a light-weight design.
Lifestraw Metal 
If you’re anxious in regards to the sturdiness of the usual Lifestraw however like their merchandise in any other case, then you definitely would possibly contemplate the Lifestraw Metal (learn my full assessment right here!). This new model packs some additional options and could be very impression resistant. Listed below are the most important variations you get with this filter.
Filters: Micro organism and Protists but additionally has a carbon filter that improves the style of water by eliminating chlorine. It additionally reduces natural chemical matter corresponding to herbicides, pesticides, and risky natural compounds (VOCs).
When you dwell in an space the place agricultural exercise is current or the place chemical substances are used typically on lawns, you need to be involved in case your water filter is nice sufficient to handle eliminating these compounds.
Professionals: Extremely sturdy but light-weight.
Cons: Considerably greater value and it’s nonetheless only a straw fashion water filter. The carbon filter is the one replaceable filter and it needs to be changed each 26 gallons. The replacements carbon filters ups the price per liter of filtered water.
My Decide
I’d positively keep on with the Survivor Filter for particular person use after having each but when I needed one thing to make use of for a gaggle or share with one other individual.
It’s merely a greater worth and has a extra rugged housing that’s extra more likely to keep collectively throughout emergencies and survival conditions the place it could get bumped or fall. I additionally like that the Survivor Filter can be utilized with a squeeze bag so that you don’t must suck water up in the event you don’t wish to.
The prefilter on the Survivor Filter is certainly a significant bonus too if you’re in a scenario the place water is very turbid corresponding to a lake or proper after a interval of rain or snow soften.
Water is your first line of survival so that you wish to have a number of filter choices and know that they’re sturdy sufficient to make it by way of a scenario. Survivor Filter is made from navy grade plastic that’s made to take an impression. If I dropped this filter on an enormous rock it actually wouldn’t do a lot apart from add a bit scratch or one thing.
A Commonplace Lifestraw doesn’t appear as handy to me.
The Lifestraw is extra cumbersome to make use of when utilizing solo. Each it and the Survivor Filter could be tough in very shallow water sources. On this case, you would need to dig out a spot to get water from or scoop it right into a squeeze bag.
I additionally nonetheless say that the Survivor Filter could be arduous to see in the event you dropped it some locations. It does have pink lettering however you continue to might wish to put some vivid tape on it until you’re actually making an attempt to be critical about Camo every little thing. Do not forget that more often than not a small filter like Survivor Filter goes to be in your bag and out of sight anyway.
So which one is interesting to you?
With any water filter there’s a lot to contemplate. All water filters have their negatives and positives. It’s my hope with these evaluations and comparisons that even when your opinion is way completely different than mine, I’ve not less than helped you concentrate on what’s best for you and your loved ones.
I’d love so that you can remark under and share your experiences with Lifestraw or Survivor water filters. On this approach we will all mix expertise and study collectively!
Additional learn: How are you going to make your water filter last more? Learn right here!
When you loved this text, contemplate following our Fb web page.
